Skip to content
John Mattone Global

Conflict Management Styles: 5 Modes and When to Use Each

John Mattone
John MattoneWorld's #1 Executive Coach
A colleague steps between two coworkers in boxing gloves: conflict management styles at work

Two of your direct reports clash in a meeting. Voices are raised, the room goes quiet, and the whole group turns to look at you. What you do next depends less on the facts than on habit, and most leaders reach for one of five conflict management styles without noticing.

In my coaching work, the style is rarely the problem; the default is. Below are the five conflict styles, when each one works, the models behind them, and why the same conflict keeps returning to your team. The short answer: match the style to the conflict situation, not your comfort.

Key Points:

  • The five conflict management styles are competing, avoiding, accommodating, compromising and collaborating.
  • Each style balances your own goals against the needs of others.
  • No single style is best, and the right approach depends on the stakes, the time and the relationship.
  • Conflict models show how hidden tension grows into open disputes, and when to step in.
  • Leaders repeat the same conflict when their default style runs on autopilot as the stakes rise.

What Are the Five Conflict Management Styles?

The five conflict management styles are competing, avoiding, accommodating, compromising and collaborating. Each one reflects how strongly you assert your own concerns and how much you cooperate with the other party. None is right or wrong in itself. Each fits some conflict situations and backfires in others.

StyleAssertivenessCooperativenessBest used whenWhat makes it work
CompetingHighLowSpeed or a vital rule is at stakeCourage, not ego
AvoidingLowLowThe issue is minor or emotions run hotRestraint, not escape
AccommodatingLowHighThe relationship matters mostHumility from strength
CompromisingModerateModerateTime is short and power is equalFairness
CollaboratingHighHighThe stakes justify a joint solutionEmpathy and openness

Most people rely on one or two styles. Those differences are normal. The trouble starts when habit, not the situation, decides how you resolve conflict.

How Does the Thomas-Kilmann Model Explain Different Styles?

The Thomas-Kilmann model places different styles on two axes: assertiveness and cooperativeness. Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann built the Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI) on it in 1974 to measure five conflict handling styles, and it remains one of the best-known conflict management models in organizations.

The Thomas Kilmann Instrument scores you on two axes:

  • Assertiveness: how strongly you pursue your own goals or needs.
  • Cooperativeness: how much you strive to meet the needs of others.

A 2024 review ranks it among the most recognized workplace conflict frameworks.

According to a study of 2,400 employees in the International Journal of Conflict Management, competing and collaborating rise with organizational level, while avoiding and accommodating fall.

A leader guides a team discussion where different conflict styles come into play

When Should You Use Each Style to Resolve Conflict?

Use competing when speed or a vital rule matters, avoiding when an issue is trivial, accommodating when the relationship matters more, compromising when time is short, and collaborating when the stakes justify a joint solution. To resolve conflict well, choose the best course for the conflict situation, not your habit.

Which style does this moment call for?

1. Competing

Competing means standing firm on your position. It fits emergencies, safety rules and moments when you must protect people or standards. Overused, it turns conviction into control, and people stop bringing you problems.

I pair it with humility: explain the decision and invite feedback afterward. Handled that way, a firm call ends in renewed trust, not resentment.

What to say: "I've heard the views, and I'm making this call now. Here is why."

2. Avoiding

Avoiding means stepping back from a disagreement for now. It works when the issue is minor, you need more context, or emotions run too hot for a useful conversation. As a pattern, though, avoidance lets disputes grow out of sight. You can't make a conflict go away by ignoring it.

A practice I give my clients for difficult conversations:

  1. Step back briefly when tension peaks.
  2. Name the fear or value driving your reaction.
  3. Return to the issue once you're clear.

What to say: "This matters. Let's discuss it properly tomorrow at nine."

3. Accommodating

Accommodating means yielding to the other person's needs. It fits when you're wrong, when the issue matters more to the other side, or when goodwill now will make future disagreements easier. Overused, it breeds quiet frustration and erodes your influence.

What to say: "You know this better than I do. Let's go with your plan."

4. Compromising

Compromising is a negotiation where both parties involved give up part of what they want. It fits when time is short, power is equal and a workable answer beats a perfect one. A fair compromise keeps progress moving toward resolution.

Settle all disputes halfway, though, and organizations drift toward mediocrity. I often remind leaders that compromise is a bridge, not a destination.

What to say: "Neither of us gets everything. Can we each compromise and review it in a month?"

5. Collaborating

Collaborating means working together until a solution meets the core interests of everyone involved. It takes time and trust, so save it for disagreements that matter to the whole group. Done well, it builds mutual understanding and stronger relationships. Used for every small task, it slows the group down.

What to say: "Help me understand what matters most to you here."

Free Download: 50 Laws of Intelligent Leadership

Get the definitive guide to the 50 laws that drive leadership excellence and organizational transformation.

Unsubscribe anytime.

We respect your privacy. See our Privacy Policy.

Which Conflict Resolution Models Explain How a Conflict Unfolds?

Three conflict resolution models explain how disputes unfold. Pondy's model shows how conflict grows from hidden to open, the Conflict Iceberg model shows what sits beneath the visible argument, and the Conflict Resolution Model sets out the skills that lead to a positive outcome for both sides.

Pondy's Five-Stage Conflict Model

According to Louis Pondy's model in Administrative Science Quarterly, conflict moves through five stages:

  1. Latent: the conditions exist, such as scarce resources or unclear roles.
  2. Perceived: someone notices the clash of goals.
  3. Felt: someone feels it as anxiety, anger or frustration.
  4. Manifest: it shows up in behavior, from open argument to quiet resistance.
  5. Aftermath: the result, or the lack of resolution, shapes the next conflict.

The perceived or felt stage is where a leader can still resolve conflict early, before positions harden.

The Conflict Iceberg Model

The Conflict Iceberg is a widely used teaching model. The surface issue is what people argue about: a deadline, a budget, a decision. Below the waterline sit the interests, assumptions, emotions and each person's belief about what is fair.

Poor communication keeps that layer hidden, so a focus on the visible problem rarely ends the conflict. Most communication barriers live below the waterline too.

The Conflict Resolution Model

According to ERIC, Australian psychologists formulated the Conflict Resolution Model as a best-practice approach to conflict resolution. Studies at the University of Tasmania found better outcomes after training in its core skills: listening, assertiveness and problem solving.

ModelWhat it explainsUse it when
Pondy's five stagesHow conflict develops over timeYou sense friction before anyone speaks
Conflict IcebergWhat sits under the stated issueA "settled" dispute keeps returning
Conflict Resolution ModelWhich skills resolve disputesYou're mediating between two people or teams
What to do at each stage of a conflict

Why Do Leaders Keep Having the Same Conflict?

Leaders keep having the same conflict because their default style runs unexamined. Every dominant trait has a version at your best and a version under pressure. When the stakes rise, most leaders fall back on the style they trust, even when the conflict situation calls for a different one.

Across more than 10,000 leadership profiles on the Mattone Leadership Enneagram Inventory (MLEI)® (as of 2020), my team and I have seen one pattern hold. Pressure does not create a new weakness. It reveals how far you have grown in the trait you already rely on.

Take the Arbitrator profile: fair, balanced and mediating at its best. When the stakes rise, the same person goes quiet, gives up control and steps away from the disagreement.

Recognize your own version of that shift, and with practice you can choose again. Character drives competence, and the style you pick in a hard conversation shows which one is doing the work.

What the Pattern Looks Like in a Real Team

On episode 368 of the Mainline Executive Coaching ACT podcast, executive coaches Maikel Bailey and Rich Baron described a culture-survey debrief with a leadership group of about twenty.

Two leaders kept "forcefully trying to direct the conversation" and disputed the results, while the rest of the group said nothing. That is competing and avoiding at one table, and the same conflict waiting to return.

How Do You Build Conflict Management Skills That Hold Under Pressure?

You build conflict management skills through deliberate practice in real disagreements: listen first, name the real issue, separate the person from the problem and follow up. These conflict resolution strategies matter because most conflicts in the workplace are never fully resolved.

According to the CIPD, only 36% of UK employees who experienced conflict at work in the previous year said it was fully resolved.

Five Conflict Resolution Strategies to Practice

  • Active listening: restate the other person's point before you respond with yours.
  • Name the real issue and the interests: explore what each side needs, not only what it wants.
  • Separate the person from the problem: describe behavior and its consequences, not character.
  • Avoid taking sides when you mediate between two people, because your job is a fair process for everyone involved.
  • Follow up: check a week later that the agreement still holds.

Each of these skills draws on emotional intelligence and on noticing your own reaction first. I've written more about the five skills that help leaders resolve conflict. I also count conflict management among the most important leadership skills.

Build a Culture Where Conflict Surfaces Early

In organizations where leaders model openness, own their mistakes and value candor over silence, concerns get raised early and engagement holds. After dealing with disputes, ask what emotions surfaced, which values were tested and what might repeat. Culture changes when behavior changes, one conversation at a time.

A team meeting on a video call

What Does Your Conflict Style Say About Your Leadership?

Your conflict style shows what you do when the stakes rise and there is no time to plan. It says less about your personality than about what you practice, and that can change. The leaders I admire most can use all five styles and choose between them on purpose.

That choice sits at the heart of Intelligent Leadership®: growth from the inside-out, so that every conflict becomes a chance to lead by example.

If you want to see your own default and how it shifts as the stakes rise, take the MLEI. If you'd like to talk it through, schedule a conversation with my team.

Free Download: 50 Laws of Intelligent Leadership

Get the definitive guide to the 50 laws that drive leadership excellence and organizational transformation.

Unsubscribe anytime.

We respect your privacy. See our Privacy Policy.

FAQs

What Are the 5 C's of Conflict Resolution?

There is no standard list of the 5 C's of conflict resolution. Most versions include the words communicate, clarify and collaborate. The same is true of the "three R's" and "four R's." Treat any of these lists as a memory aid rather than a model, and focus on the skills that resolve conflict.

What Are the 7 Stages of Conflict Resolution?

Seven-stage versions vary by source, and none is standard. The best-known stage model has five: Pondy's latent, perceived, felt, manifest and aftermath stages. For conflict resolution itself, the Conflict Resolution Model from Australian psychologists rests on three skills: listening, assertiveness and problem solving.

What Are the Four Styles of Conflict?

The best-known framework, the Thomas Kilmann Instrument, lists five conflict management styles, not four: competing, avoiding, accommodating, compromising and collaborating. Lists with a different number reflect differences between frameworks, so check which model a source uses before you form an opinion of your results.

Which Conflict Management Style Is Most Effective?

No style is most effective in every case. Collaborating often gives the most lasting resolution when time allows, but competing works better in an emergency, and avoiding is wiser for trivial issues. The most effective leaders treat the five styles as strategies and choose deliberately rather than dealing with every conflict the same way.

John Mattone

About the Author

John Mattone

World's #1 Executive Coach

World's #1 Executive Coach and author of 11 books. Former coach to Steve Jobs and PepsiCo CEO Roger Enrico. Pioneer of Intelligent Leadership, transforming nearly one million leaders across 55 countries.

World's #1 Executive Coach (Globalgurus.org, 2019-2024)M.S. Industrial/Organizational PsychologyFormer Coach to Steve JobsAuthor of 11 Books (5 Bestsellers)Distinguished Senior Fellow, Hult International Business School

Ready to Transform Your Leadership?

Discover how Intelligent Leadership coaching can help you reach your full potential.

Get 50 Laws

Download