Skip to content
John Mattone Global

The Coaching Leadership Style: A Transformational Approach to Leadership

John Mattone
John MattoneWorld's #1 Executive Coach
Coaching leadership style in practice: a leader at a whiteboard talks with her seated team

When one of your team members brings you a problem you could solve in thirty seconds, a coaching leadership style asks you to hold back and develop them through questions, feedback and support instead of handing over the answer. It feels slower in the moment, and it builds a team that needs you less.

I have spent decades coaching leaders, and the ones who make this leadership style work share one habit: they keep checking whether it works. Coaching is a practice you keep adjusting. Below: what the style is, how it looks in a normal week, the research, its pros and cons, and three field tests.

Key Points:

  • A coaching leadership style develops employees through questions, feedback and support rather than instructions.
  • Coaching leaders listen more than they talk and hold back advice so team members solve their own problems.
  • Research links coaching leadership to stronger employee engagement, motivation and team performance, though most studies are small.
  • A coaching leadership style works best with employees who want growth and works poorly in a crisis that needs a fast decision.
  • You can tell coaching is working when reviews hold no surprises, the room stays open and people bring you fewer decisions.

What is a coaching leadership style?

A coaching leadership style is an approach in which leaders act as coaches: asking open questions, giving constructive feedback and developing each employee's skills and knowledge over time. The focus is long-term professional growth and better judgment, not compliance with today's instructions. Some people call it coach leadership or a coaching management style.

In Daniel Goleman's study of 3,871 executives, coaching was one of six leadership approaches and the one leaders used least often, yet its impact on climate and performance was "markedly positive."

Coaching and mentoring are not the same: a mentor offers guidance from their own path, while coaching leaders help team members find theirs.

How does coaching compare with the other leadership approaches?

Goleman found that the most effective leaders switch between styles to suit the situation and the organization. Here is where the coaching leadership style sits among the six:

StyleWhat does the leader do?When does it work?
CoerciveDemands immediate complianceA genuine crisis or turnaround
AuthoritativeGives clear direction toward a visionWhen organizational change needs a new course
AffiliativePuts people and harmony firstRepairing relationships and trust
DemocraticBuilds agreement through collaborationWhen buy-in or fresh ideas matter
PacesettingSets high standards and models themA motivated, highly skilled team
CoachingFocuses on the development of employeesEmployees who want to improve their performance

The need is real. According to Gallup's State of the Global Workplace, only 20% of employees worldwide were engaged at work in 2025, so employee engagement is a gap almost every organization shares.

What are the characteristics of coaching leaders?

Coaching leaders share five characteristics: active listening, open-ended questions, the discipline to hold back advice, constructive feedback aimed at the future, and high emotional intelligence. Together these characteristics build trust and psychological safety, so team members feel valued and supported as individuals and are willing to try, fail and learn.

In my experience, not all leaders are natural coaches, but every leader can develop coaching skills through practice and deliberate strategies, starting by creating a safe and supportive environment where employees can discuss mistakes without fear.

Two colleagues review work on a tablet together while one points out a detail

The coaching skills that matter most

The coaching skills leaders need most are listening, asking and waiting. A good question hands the thinking back to the employee. Waiting means resisting the urge to rescue them with your own advice, even when you already know the answer.

  • Active listening: Active listening means reflecting back what you heard before you respond, which builds understanding on both sides.
  • Open questions: Asking the right question gives guidance on problem solving without taking it over.
  • Holding back advice: Advice feels helpful, but advice given too early teaches team members to wait for yours.
  • Forward-looking feedback: Constructive feedback improves performance when it keeps the focus on what to do next time.
  • Emotional intelligence: High emotional intelligence is essential for coaching leaders, because you have to read how feedback lands.

Which coaching principles guide a coaching leader?

Five coaching principles guide a coaching leader: work on the other person's agenda, assess where they are, challenge them to stretch, support them through the stretch, and help them learn from past experiences. These coaching principles turn coaching leadership from a personality trait into a repeatable practice you can apply in any conversation.

The middle three come from a widely taught coaching model: Assess, Challenge and Support. The other two keep the coaching relationship honest and the relationships on your team strong.

The five coaching principles in practice

Applied consistently, these coaching principles help employees align personal goals with organizational goals, achieve both, and take responsibility for their own growth and professional development.

Coaching leadership examples: what does it look like in a normal week?

Coaching leadership shows up in ordinary moments, not special sessions. In a normal week it looks like a one-to-one where you ask more than you tell, a team meeting where team members work out solutions together, and a calm conversation after a mistake.

Your team, and eventually the whole organization, copies what you do. Social learning theory, Albert Bandura's idea that people learn by watching others, explains why leaders who coach become an example for others to follow.

1. In a one-to-one

A team member asks how to handle challenges with a difficult client. Instead of offering solutions, you ask what she has tried, what outcome she wants and what her first step will be. She leaves with her own plan and the confidence to own it.

You spent ten minutes creating a decision-maker instead of a follower.

2. In a team meeting

A project is slipping. Rather than reassigning tasks, you ask the team members what is getting in the way and which strategies they would try first. A collaborative approach like this tends to improve collaboration and team performance, and it builds a coaching culture of growth and collaboration.

People whose ideas get used speak up sooner, and that is how communication and trust grow inside a team.

3. After a mistake

A team member misses a deadline. You ask what happened, what they would do differently and what support they need. The focus moves from blame to the lesson, and continuous learning becomes part of the team's culture.

A red figure stands in front of a group of wooden figures, like a leader facing the team

Does coaching leadership work? What the research shows

Yes. The research on coaching leadership is consistently positive, though most studies are small. Coaching leadership has been linked to higher creative performance and motivation, stronger coaching skills among managers, better team performance and greater leader effectiveness. The honest summary: consistent evidence, built on samples of a few dozen to a few hundred employees.

What the studies found

  • Creativity: In a study of more than 300 employees, coaching leadership positively affected employees' creative performance. Psychological empowerment and constructive voice behavior, meaning people feel able to act and to speak up, carried the effect, and the authors argue that coaching raises internal motivation.
  • Skills and performance: In a controlled trial with 41 managers, a coaching-based leadership development program inside one organization improved coaching skills and performance, and both held four months later. Work engagement rose right after the program.
  • Effectiveness: In a PLOS ONE study of 70 leaders, gains in authentic leadership during coaching had the largest effect on leader effectiveness.

None of it is large-scale or randomized, so treat it as direction, not proof. It matches what I have seen in my own work: coaching leaders achieve more when they keep at it.

What are the pros and cons of a coaching leadership style?

The main pros of a coaching leadership style are higher employee engagement, stronger problem solving, better retention and a pipeline of future leaders. The main cons are the time it takes, slower short-term results and a poor fit in a crisis. Every leadership style has limits, and knowing when to switch is part of the skill.

Goleman was blunt about the challenges. Coaching "makes little sense when employees, for whatever reason, are resistant to learning or changing their ways," and it fails when the leader lacks the expertise to help.

Pros, cons and what to do about them

Pro or conWhat happens?Which strategies help?
Pro: engagementEmployees feel valued and show more commitmentRecognize progress, not only results
Pro: talent retentionDevelopment gives employees a reason to stayDiscuss personal and professional growth every quarter
Pro: leadership pipelineEmployees build the skills to lead and decideHand over real decision making early
Con: timeCoaching requires a time investment from leadersBuild coaching into existing processes
Con: slower resultsAsking takes longer than tellingFocus coaching on what matters, direct the rest
Con: people who want adviceSome employees want an answer, not questionsMentor briefly, then ask what they learned
When to switchA crisis, a fast decision or someone who does not want to grow; organizational change can need clear direction tooLead directly now, coach in the debrief

Many leaders I coach ask me how they can shift from directing to coaching leadership without losing control. My answer is always the same: coaching is not about losing control; it is about gaining influence through relationships.

Four signs that a team member is ready to be coached, from Daniel Goleman's research on leadership styles

Free Download: 50 Laws of Intelligent Leadership

Get the definitive guide to the 50 laws that drive leadership excellence and organizational transformation.

Unsubscribe anytime.

We respect your privacy. See our Privacy Policy.

How can you tell your coaching is working?

You can tell your coaching leadership is working when your team members' behavior changes in ways you can recognize. The co-hosts of JMG's podcast, Rich Baron and Maikel Bailey, offer three field tests: whether team members can predict their annual review, whether the room goes quiet when you walk in, and whether employees bring you fewer decisions.

Leaders can run all three in a week without a survey, and each tells you more about your relationships than a general sense of how the team feels.

Can your people predict their annual review?

If team members are surprised by their annual review, the coaching has not happened. Coaching leadership emphasizes continuous feedback rather than just annual reviews, so review processes should only summarize conversations you have already had. A surprise means the feedback arrived too late to support anyone's growth.

As Rich Baron put it on the podcast: "if your people have no clue what's coming before an annual review, how can you sit there and tell me or anybody else you know your people?" His co-host, Maikel Bailey, adds the cost: “You're also creating a culture of discouragement.”

Does the room go quiet when you walk in?

If conversation stops when you walk in, Rich Baron says, ask yourself why. It means your people respect you, or you are not part of the group, and most leaders pick the flattering reading. With open communication and a healthy relationship, the talk carries on.

Run the room-goes-quiet test on purpose: notice which meetings go silent when you arrive. Where coaching leadership is working, people across the organization keep talking because speaking up is safe. That free communication is the culture you are building.

Are they bringing you fewer decisions?

Effective coaching leadership makes people need you less. On episode 372 of the podcast, Maikel Bailey says coaching exists to cut umbilical cords, not to add another. If individual team members bring you the same decisions they brought six months ago, the coaching is creating dependence instead of judgment.

Bailey describes a cycle that builds self-trust: an assignment, learning from it, applying it, incorporating it into how the person already works, and then repeating.

Over time, people move from asking "am I doing this right?" to trusting their own judgment with confidence.

Flowchart with three questions that tell a leader whether their coaching is working and what to change when a check fails

Coaching leadership vs leadership coaching: what's the difference?

Coaching leadership is how you lead your team: you act as the coach. Leadership coaching is a professional service in which a coach works with you on your own development. One is a leadership style; the other is how leaders learn it. Many leaders need the second before the first comes naturally.

Leadership coaching and coaching leadership meet because coaching is hard to learn alone. Goleman observed that many managers lack a working understanding of coaching, especially of ongoing performance feedback that motivates people instead of creating fear.

What effective leadership coaching adds

Effective leadership coaching gives you a coach of your own, so you experience the style before you practice it. You get feedback on how you lead under pressure, a development plan built on your strengths and the skills you still need, and someone who holds you to it. That is where professional development turns into habit.

The best managers both give and receive coaching. Structured leadership development speeds up both across an organization by creating time for practice. If you want that kind of support for your own coaching leadership, Intelligent Leadership® Executive Coaching is built around it.

Why coaching others starts with self-awareness

You cannot coach others well until you understand how you lead at your best and under pressure. Self-awareness helps you recognize when you rescue people with advice, when you stop listening, and when stress pushes you back to telling. That understanding is where personal growth and better coaching both begin.

To me, great leadership starts on the inside and works its way out, which is why self-awareness comes first for coaching leaders.

What kind of great leader does a coaching style make?

A coaching style makes the kind of great leader whose team members achieve more with them than anywhere else. It helps leaders build trust and stronger relationships, and it leaves a team that finds its own solutions. It also asks the leader to keep adjusting: the real work behind the coaching leadership style.

I believe character drives competence. The leaders who coach best are not the ones with the most strategies; they measure success by their people's progress and change course when it stalls. Start this week: ask instead of tell in one conversation.

Explore the IL coaching process. Or schedule a conversation. The ROI calculator shows what coaching could return for your organization.

Free Download: 50 Laws of Intelligent Leadership

Get the definitive guide to the 50 laws that drive leadership excellence and organizational transformation.

Unsubscribe anytime.

We respect your privacy. See our Privacy Policy.

FAQs

What does a leadership coach do?

Leadership coaching is one-to-one work with a leader to improve how they lead. The coach gathers feedback, builds the leader's understanding of strengths and blind spots, agrees on a few development goals to focus on and meets regularly to track progress and offer support. Unlike a mentor, the coach usually sits outside the organization, which makes honest feedback easier.

What is the 70/30 rule in coaching?

The 70/30 rule is a common rule of thumb: the coach listens about 70 percent of the time and talks about 30 percent. It is a reminder, not a research finding. For coaching leaders, it means active listening comes first, questions come second, and advice comes last, if at all.

What are the four types of coaching styles?

There is no single standard list of four or five coaching styles. It makes more sense to think of a range from directive, where the coach tells, to non-directive, where the coach asks. A coaching leader sits toward the non-directive end and moves toward direction only when the person lacks the knowledge to find the answer.

What are the pillars of coaching?

Lists of five or seven pillars vary, but most come down to trust, listening, powerful questions, honest feedback and accountability. Trust builds relationships in which people are willing to be coached, listening and questions help them think, feedback shows them where they stand, and accountability turns commitment into action.

What makes a great leader a good coach?

The best leaders become good coaches by caring more about the other person's personal growth than about being right. That means patience, curiosity and the skills and expertise to help, combined with the discipline to let people struggle a little. These leaders measure success by how much their people can do without them.

John Mattone

About the Author

John Mattone

World's #1 Executive Coach

World's #1 Executive Coach and author of 11 books. Former coach to Steve Jobs and PepsiCo CEO Roger Enrico. Pioneer of Intelligent Leadership, transforming nearly one million leaders across 55 countries.

World's #1 Executive Coach (Globalgurus.org, 2019-2024)M.S. Industrial/Organizational PsychologyFormer Coach to Steve JobsAuthor of 11 Books (5 Bestsellers)Distinguished Senior Fellow, Hult International Business School

Ready to Transform Your Leadership?

Discover how Intelligent Leadership coaching can help you reach your full potential.

Get 50 Laws

Download